Table based on the paper “How Far is the Human Hand, a Review on Anthropomorphic End Effectors” published by the University of Bologna. This version compiled by Veronique Perdereau at Pierre et Marie Curie University
|
Robot Hand id. |
BH8-series Barrett hand Barrett technology, inc. USA
|
DIST Hand Universita di Genova Italy
|
Robonaut Hand NASA Johnson Space Center USA |
DLR Hand II DLR-German Aerospace Center Germany
|
Ultralight Hand Research center of Karlsruhe Germany |
GIFU Hand Gifu University Japan
|
Shadow Hand Shadow Robot Company Ltd United-Kingdom |
UB Hand III Bologna University Italy
|
|
Year |
1997 |
1998 |
1999 |
2000 |
2000 |
2001 |
2004 |
2004 |
|
Status |
Commercial use |
Research prototype |
Research prototype |
Research prototype |
Research prototype |
Research prototype |
Available for purchase |
Research prototype |
|
Structures and materials |
3 fingers (opposable), Electrical revolute brushless motors, Spur and worm gear transmissions, Fair contact surface smoothness |
3 fingers and one opposable thumb, Electrical revolute brushless motors, Tendons routed through pulleys |
4 fingers and one opposable thumb, Electrical revolute brushless motors, Flex-shaft + lead screw transmissions, Kevlar body armor coated with Teflon |
4 fingers and one opposable thumb, Electrical revolute motors, Harmonic drives/gears transmissions, Silicone finger surface |
4 fingers and one opposable thumb, Flexible fluidic actuators, Direct drive transmissions, Silicone-rubber glove |
4 fingers and one opposable thumb, Built-in DC Maxon servomotors, Worm gear transmissions |
4 fingers and one opposable thumb, Air Muscles, Tendons, Layer of soft polyurethane flesh, Thin polycarbonate fingernails |
4 fingers and one opposable thumb, DC brushed motor, Pulling tendons, Continuous compliant pulps
|
|
Sensory-motor skills |
4 controlled DOF Motor position sensors (optical incremental encoders) Strain-gauges based joint torque sensors |
16 controlled DOF Motor position sensors hall-effect based joint position sensors 3-axis fingertip force sensors
|
14 controlled DOF (2 wrist + 12 fingers) Motor position sensors Joint position sensors Tendon tension sensors Tactile force sensors (FSR Force Sensing Resistor technology) |
13 controlled DOF Motor position sensors Joint position sensors (potentiometers) Strain-gauged based joint torque sensors 6-axis fingertip force sensors |
13 controlled DOF (3 wrist + 10 fingers) Joint position bending sensors Pressure sensors in finger links |
16 controlled DOF Motor position sensors 6-axis fingertip force sensors Distributed resistive tactile sensors |
24 DOF, 20 controlled (16/12 fingers + 5 thumb + 2 wrist + 1 palm) Muscle pressure sensors Hall effect based joint position sensors
Distributed tactile force sensors (contact, force, direction)
|
16 controlled DOF Motor position sensors Tendon force sensors strain gauges based joint position sensors |
|
Feedback control |
No sensory feedback Patented clutch mechanism distributes grasp forces Patented reconfigurable spreading fingers |
Position feedback |
No sensory feedback |
Position feedback (impedance control) |
No sensory feedback Self adaptable properties of the hand |
No sensory feedback |
Position feedback (low level joint position and joint stiffness control) |
Incomplete sensory feedback Motor level control Impedance control
|
|
Functional capabilities |
Power grasp and precision grasp |
Power grasp and precision grasp |
Power grasp, precision grasp and human-like fine manipulation |
Power grasp, precision grasp and human-like fine manipulation |
Power grasp and precision grasp |
Power grasp and precision grasp |
Power grasp, precision grasp and human like fine manipulation |
Power grasp, precision grasp and human like fine manipulation |
|
Autonomy |
Non autonomous |
Non autonomous |
Remotely operated via visual feedback |
Pre-planning: performs previously stored trajectories and hand poses |
Pre-planning: performs patterns of movements : position and torque of every joints |
Non autonomous |
Semi-autonomous |
Semi autonomous |
Table based on the paper “How Far is the Human Hand, a Review on Anthropomorphic End Effectors” published by the University of Bologna. This version compiled by Veronique Perdereau at Pierre et Marie Curie University